Meet Elaine: Why We Need Low Income Housing

I first met Elaine at the Glendale Winter Shelter. She is a very sweet, older woman who has lived on the streets homeless for 20 years. At the shelter, she would come up to us and ask that we help her friends. She never asked for herself, but for those she felt were hurting worse than she was. She was always kind, polite, and never once was a problem to anyone. As I spent more time with Elaine, I noticed she would be kind to people who were not kind to her, always saying “thank you” even when people were turning her away.

The Glendale Winter Shelter closed early this year, leaving around 150 homeless people with no place to go. Around three weeks ago, I was in the PATH Achieve outreach van when we noticed Elaine sleeping on the sidewalk. Near the end of a winter shelter season, we try to help those who are in need of housing the most. Elaine was at the top of our list. She is somewhat naive and can easily be taken advantage of on the streets. There was some money left to hotel voucher a few people while we tried to plug into services. We had tried earlier to connect with Elaine, but it didn’t work. This time she said yes, and we drove to the hotel.


Immediately we noticed a night-and-day improvement. Elaine’s hygiene improved. She was washing her own clothes. Once she had a little dignity, she was like a whole new woman. At first, we didn’t know if she would stay, but she adapted well and started to even ask, “Can you get me a house?”

I remember grocery shopping with her the very first time. She wanted Hawaiian Punch, but didn’t want cups. She said, “I’m homeless, and I usually drink out of the bottle. I don’t want you to spend money on me.” That wrecked me, and of course we bought her cups to use.

Elaine is disabled and cannot work. She receives a little over $900 per month from SSI, but she cannot get food stamps. The hotel voucher money runs out in a few days and she will be back out on the streets, homeless! Section 8 housing is frozen indefinitely, Homelessness Prevention and Rapid Re-Housing Program (HPRP) grants are not for chronic homeless, and there is not enough Shelter Plus Care funding to help her (or the thousands like her).

In desperation, a co-worker started to look for low income housing. The lowest we could find is $700 a month for an unfurnished single. We knew it would be a stretch. Living off $200 a month for everything but housing is crazy, but she is a senior and can eat daily at a local senior center, and we would be there to help. Now we needed to come up with security deposit for her to move in.

We had been looking into grant assistance that we can sometimes get for move-in expenses, but all money had dried up. I put out a ‘Hail Mary’ tweet on Twitter, and in no time my good friend David Ruis and the Basileia Community offered to help. You’d think raising money would be the hard part.

We started to fill out the rental application, drove to the Social Security office to get proof of income, and then proceeded to the property manager’s office. All afternoon you could tell Elaine was excited. She kept asking, “When can I move in?”

We arrived at the office. The girl at the first desk started to look at the application and then asked for last known address. We all said in unison, “She’s homeless.” I wish I could have taken a photo of that woman’s face. Her jaw dropped and clearly she was shocked. Right then and there I knew we would soon get an “excuse.” The obvious one was that Elaine’s income is not three times higher than the rent. But this is a month-to-month lease on an apartment complex that should be used to the type of people who have very low incomes.

My favorite part of that horrible moment was when the lady who gave Elaine the excuses somehow had to run out the door to leave for the day, Elaine said to her, “Thank you very much for trying to help me. It was nice to meet you.”

The lady before she abruptly left handed everything to another girl in the office. This second woman seemed very nice, but said she would have to check with someone else. (There were several backroom meetings after we walked in.) She took my co-worker’s credit check deposit money and said she’d get back to us. We never heard back from her, or anyone else at that property management company.

I know first hand how hard it is to go from homeless to housed. Luckily, I am a fighter. But for the thousands of sweet, innocent seniors now homeless there really is very little hope. I cannot tell you the ending to Elaine’s story, or even my own for that matter. I am 49 with no assets. There is a very good chance I will spend my senior years on the streets because there is very little affordable housing for seniors, and even with government assistance I will not be able to afford housing.

Housing alone will not cure homelessness. We must also be community conscious. Elaine would rather live on the streets where she has social contact with people she knows than be housed in a different part of town.

I honestly don’t have the answer here. I sure wish I did. In a day or two if we cannot find low income housing for Elaine, I will be one of the team that drives her back to where we found her on the sidewalk. Imagine dropping your grandmother off to sleep on a sidewalk.

[Ask] [Bloglines] [del.icio.us] [Digg] [Facebook] [Fark] [Faves] [Furl] [Google] [Hugg] [LinkedIn] [Ma.gnolia] [Mixx] [MySpace] [MyWeb] [Newsvine] [Reddit] [Squidoo] [StumbleUpon] [Technorati] [Twitter] [Windows Live] [Yahoo!] [Email]
  • http://twitter.com/shikemore Michael Shore

    Mark – this may be more than obvious – do all of these places have waiting lists? http://www.hud.gov/apps/section8/results.cfm?ci…

  • crystalryan

    why not senior housing? an “old folks home” there is a problem here in my city as well as all over country. not to be racist which I AM NOT! but the shelters here are full of white and african americans that were born here. The new somolian, sudan, and whatever else are getting housing fast! I was in an homeless shelter with my kids. I watched them get brand new furniture delivered to them from city assistance and their rent all paid and are even given vehicles! We need to make sure our own are taken care of before anyone else. The somolians are running the salvation army here now and most of the assistance offices. There is no help for me anymore. If your American you shit outa luck.

  • http://hardlynormal.com hardlynormal

    Hi Mike,

    Not obvious, we are hitting everything. this is one of the many that fall through the 'safety net'

  • http://hardlynormal.com hardlynormal

    Hi Crystal,

    we are trying everything including senior housing

    I am sorry to hear about your situation, and I honestly feel your frustration. That said, although unfortunately there is racism everywhere, I have yet to see what you are talking about as I travel the country. What I do see is 'favoritism'. a select group of people will receive all of the best donations before general population. I have seen this in churches and nonprofits. Too be honest, favoritism is hard to stop. It really depends on the wisdom of the leadership. I personally will not give donations through the 'system' and give to people who I see has the need.

    Unfortunately, in all walks of life, and even social-economic levels, people will abuse people. Enron is a great example of abuse

  • http://homeword-unbound.blogspot.com/ Slum Jack

    “There is a very good chance I will spend my senior years on the streets …”

    I've got 8 years on you. And I am homeless. I also don't have that $900 monthly that Elaine's got.

    Only a couple of years ago, I was on the other side of the rental desk, working as a property manager.

    The collision of realities and personal predicaments has been more than ironic. And you, Elaine and I are tragically far from alone in these kinds of circumstances. Perhaps “predicaments” is the more fitting word, unfortunately.

    Combine “career knockouts”, damaged or ruined credit, no particular income, homeless status and condition (and all the ways that functionally hobbles), “age-ism”, etc. and I now know first-hand what this demise is like… from both sides of the desk. I had previously mostly known from within the context of trying to help folks get in.

    I see you're a man of faith. Right now, I can't share faith that there IS a “solution” to these kinds of combinations of factors, frankly. What's had and kept me going, though, despite the bizarre hardships of the … predicament … is what I've come to suspect does need to be bolstered. And shared with others. Because there may be no “end” to the circumstances for some of us. More of us than ever, actually.

    And we're still here. Every day. Every night. Anyway.

  • marilynharris

    This is an issue in every city and every neighborhood. What we need to do is crate collaborative partners to build housing..take for example Habitant Housing, I know they have qualifiers to get a house. Why not ask them and other builders to do a JV to build low income housing. The homeless I am sure would be happy to help build as well.

    A couple of times have have been homeless..jobless..it was amazing to discover my friends even turned their heads and would say no you can't stay here. That just floored me..People need to to look around and help their friends and neighbors.

  • crystalryan

    I'm sure there must be something we could do. If we all banned together and brought it to the proper org, attention wouldn't they have to fix the problem if the public realises what's really going on here? I'm sick of them being here for only a short time as they already gained ownership of a gas station, cab companies, they are running our local Salvation Army where they use to be open to help the homeless aren't anymore since the man running it now is Somolian? Let's look at the big picture here.

  • crystalryan

    The new property they built all around my town to make room for more immigrants. The shelters are full of American's. We need to do something about this.

  • crystalryan

    I'm sure there must be something we could do. If we all banned together and brought it to the proper org, attention wouldn't they have to fix the problem if the public realises what's really going on here? I'm sick of them being here for only a short time as they already gained ownership of a gas station, cab companies, they are running our local Salvation Army where they use to be open to help the homeless aren't anymore since the man running it now is Somolian? Let's look at the big picture here.

  • crystalryan

    The new property they built all around my town to make room for more immigrants. The shelters are full of American's. We need to do something about this.

  • http://www.titidirectonline.co.uk/mobile-phones Dual Sim Phone

    great read

  • ResilientHeart

    Mark, you write candidly, piercingly honestly as only a soul who has walked through (or is walking through) the fire can.

    Have you checked with Salvation Army? I wrote to them both in the local community and their national office and received a reply. They could not help me due to my particular circumstances, but they were genuine, the only ones unafraid of the realities of life, and with a natural compassion and grace.

    Blessings to you in each and every step. From one fighter to another, I wish for you more than words express.

    I am grateful to have found you on Twitter and my curiosity brought me here.

    ResilientHeart
    http://thefightofmylife.blogspot.com

  • Jody

    I don't know if this has been investigated but a person or family (as opposed to a commercial company) with a backyard cottage/granny unit or even just a spare room may be willing to give Elaine a chance and hopefully for less than $700. Good luck to you on this!!

  • Jody

    I don't know if this has been investigated but a person or family (as opposed to a commercial company) with a backyard cottage/granny unit or even just a spare room may be willing to give Elaine a chance and hopefully for less than $700. Good luck to you on this!!